
To date, all previous editions of Teacher Tales have been written from my perspective as a teacher. In this episode, I write from the perspective of a student, me, about a teacher I had in the seventh grade: Mr. Willard Gerber.
.
From the first week that I started the sixth grade at my new elementary school, I was surrounded by students talking in mock horror of the infamous "Mr. Gerber," who taught art at the junior high to all seventh graders. "He's a faggot," some would say. "He takes his boy students into his back room and makes them suck his dick." I didn't really believe this was true, and I can't imagine that many other kids did either, but it was a great source of scandalous amusement for sixth graders the entire year, and I even found myself getting caught up in the hype a bit. Count after count surfaced of older brothers or friends who had experienced the hand of Mr. Gerber.
.
I still remember the first day of seventh grade art. Everyone walked into the classroom with great trepidation, stifled grins and sideways glances. Nobody wanted to sit at the front. Mr. Gerber certainly possessed unfortunate characteristics that undoubtedly fed the fire. First of all, his name was Willard Gerber. If he had been named Rob Thomas or Colton Ford or Sean Penn, things wouldn't have been blown quite so much out of proportion. He had a long, severe nose, huge square glasses, a nasal voice and a slight lisp. Most days he wore polyester smocks in olive, mustard, and burgundy tones, and he drove an old Dodge Dart around town all by himself, looking not unlike a sad toad. He seemed to be an outcast among the faculty of the junior high, and I wondered from time to time if he had any friends at all.
.
The manner in which kids treated him was appalling. They mocked him to his face, made detestable jokes about him behind his back yet loud enough so he could hear, and even taunted him with slurs that made me squirm. He seemed to just ignore it. He just took it, and taught his lessons.
.
Often he needed help in the supply room to prepare for projects. He gave each student an opportunity to help, some accepted, and some declined with sheepish troublemaker grins. I accepted. I worked in the supply room for my allotted week, and of course, Mr. Gerber was nothing but professional in his interactions with me. Nevertheless, I was recipient to the usual teasing that came along with helping in the supply room. "So how did you like sucking Mr. Gerber's dick? I'll bet you liked it," they would sneer.
.
Despite it all, Mr. Gerber was an outstanding art teacher. He was precise, methodical, encouraging, and downright talented. Each student produced an array of art projects using a variety of elements, each student was successful. And somehow, in spite of the taunting, he managed to maintain decent classroom discipline.
.
Surprisingly enough, I didn't give that much thought to Mr. Gerber and his plight, probably because I was preoccupied with my own. But now, reflecting on the past, I ask myself, did Mr. Gerber go about each and every day with a heavy heart brought on by hatred, lies, and inhumane treatment? Did he love teaching so much that he just put up with the abuse? Did the administration know anything about these things? Did parents? Did anyone do anything to stop it all? Or, perhaps there actually was some kind of truth to all the rumors. Maybe he got away with crimes because in the early 80's not as much was done about inappropriate teacher-child interactions. It could be that I am missing a very critical part of the story.
.
From my perspective, Mr. Willard Gerber was a victim of cruelty perpetuated by brutal young teenagers with a mob mentality. Perhaps they got away with it because the other adults at the time were too uncomfortable to address the topic, much less do anything about it.
.
When I reached high school, Mr. Gerber took an early retirement, and I never heard anything more about him. But every once in a while, I would see him around town, driving his Dodge Dart in a polyester smock.
.
Whatever became of Mr. Gerber?
.


27 comments:
I'd like to think that Mr. Gerber was secure enough in himself not to care what the students said or thought, and was just happy to be doing something he loved.
So that's what I'm going to think.
This is so moving. And I think you hit on the critical point here, which is that stories are a matter of perspective. We often don't have the all the pieces to the puzzle, but we want to know what is the whole picture.
Excellent, Jason.
P.S. The early retirement makes me wonder. It could mean very little, it could mean a lot.
Did you Google him?
I feel really bad for Mr. Gerber. Don't tell me if he turns out to be a creep..okay!? I want to remember him like you do!!!
Writing about your teacher made me remember an old grade school teacher that scared the piss out of me - literally. Miss Dickheart. Real name. I may have to blog about her. I'm sure she's dead now so it is safe.
What a very sad commentary, Jason. I can only imagine the pain that poor man had to live with each and every day, knowing he was being mocked and ridiculed by all those little brats.
Why don't you look him up, see if he's still around?
Justine :o )
Look him up. Really.
Or, leave him in your mind as exactly what he was to you. A great art teacher.
Yep - at my school, he was Mr. Hurst - taught 6th grade science and history. Everyone called him Happy Hurst. You could've described him with the polyester and uniqueness. Sad, the way kids treat some teachers - and other kids, too.
man, kids can be mean....or maybe....
I think you are so right, we don't always have all the peices to the story. We judge before knowing.
Kids can be so damn cruel. Yet, you bring up the point that maybe there was some truth to the rumors. My gut says there wasn't. I know such things went much more unreported back then but out of all those kids, something would have come out, don't you think?
This post brings back to my memory of an English/creative writing teacher I had in high school. He came from New York and I will admit that he looked and acted different. Coming to our small rural community, with the small minds that were filled with racism and anti anything that went against the "norm", to teach had to be really hard.
Rumors flew about him being gay...of him doing stuff. He was a great teacher and he spent extra time with any student that needed extra help or to just talk. He road a bike or walked instead of driving a car...he was made fun of for this. It really was sad that he wasn't given a chance by most of the community.
He only taught for 2 years but he out of all the teachers I ever had, had the most positive impact on my life. Not only did he encourage me to write, he helped me through some very tough life situations. I know I am not the only one he helped.
It doesn't matter that it was true of him being gay but the rest were lies. I didn't care. I just knew that he was someone that truely cared about kids and teaching. He cared about what was happening to us outside of the classroom. He talked about things that other adults wouldn't talk about. Regardless of how he was talked about and mistreated, he turned the other cheek.
Eventually he was pretty much ran out of town. Sad. I will never forget this teacher and I have always wished I could thank him for not only what he did for me but what he taught me by his actions.
Great post Jason!
Wow. Great post and you have such a great memory of this, it must have affected you somehow. I feel for Mr. Gerber. I would guess there was not truth to the stories(would not bet my life on it) but you know how middle school kids are...they are terrorists.
I hope that the taunting of the terrorists did not follow him home each day...but how could it not?
I think it would be something if you could talk to him--even just to tell him you thought he was a great art teacher. What teacher doesn't want to hear that?
We had a gym teacher in high school that the rumors swirled around for years--eventually he was fired and prosecuted for inappropriate behavior with a female student.
You never disappoint your readers, Jason!! This was a wonderful tribute to Mr. Gerber. I'm going to take the stance that none of those rumors were true (God willing!) and that he was just a truly dedicated teacher. Don't you wish you could have a sit-down with him, maybe over coffee, and just tell him everything you just told us? If you find him, you must update us!
I think that even the most secure people in the world would be hurt by endless taunting. I just read 19 minutes. I am pretty sure that was one of your book club books. It broke my heart. And the thing that makes me the saddest of all is that I know it will never end. We can stop some bullying but we can never stop it completely.
I hope he is alive and well and making projects in his retirement community. And more than that, I hope he is loved. Very, very loved.
Unfortunately, we all have a Mr. Gerber in our past school life. Yes, kids can be cruel. And ignorant. To teachers and to each other. I agree that I hope your Mr. Gerber is alive and well and very much loved. No matter how he chooses to live.
so much to say here..... but I will just say that I am glad that you posted this. There are many many places, including the same place we grew up, where people still treat people this way.
Stories like that make me so sad. I have a friend who has told me about a teacher that the kids all hated and harassed- and she still insists this teacher "deserved it." And my friend was even a teacher for a few years! It baffles me the way kids seem to dehumanize teachers, you know?
We had a teacher like that in my HS - Mr. Anderson (Suz would remember him). Kids said HORRIBLE things about him. It's almost like teenagers forget that teachers are human beings....
I had how mean people can be. Just downright hateful.
But every once in a while, I would see him around town, driving his Dodge Dart in a polyester smock.
That gives me the idea he was pretty comfortable being HIM, when all was said and done. I hope I am right...
~Mary
It's just part of the bullying culture that takes place in schools. And why is it that it seems the worst thing you can say about someone is that they're gay?
Without knowing the whole story, it's hard to know how to feel. I rather like the idea that he was secure enough and loved teaching enough that he didn't care about the gossip. And as for early retirement - so many districts have great retirement benefits, it wasn't uncommon for people to take early retirement. And teaching can burn you out - precisely because a sane person has to transcend this kind of nastiness to survive.
I'm glad you enjoyed him as a teacher, and agree that it would be a cool thing if someday you could tell him so.
Great post.
I think maybe we all had some sort of teacher that was different and targeted for whatever made them weird to us. Looking back it's easier to be objective and see that maybe they weren't so weird afterall. As for me, I hope the stories weren't true and the early retirement was by choice.
I hope a lot of the teenagers who you've written about here grew up and realized how cruel they had been and go out of their way to be kinder to others and to teach kindness in an effort to make up for it. That's my *hope*.
Beautiful post, Jason. It reminds me of how devastated I was when a favorite 7th grade teacher committed suicide over Christmas Break. That was 35 years ago and I still think of Mr.Kessen, may he RIP. I also send peace to Mr.Gerber.
The fact that he just put up with the cruelty means that he must have loved teaching and art. I'd like to think that he was secure in himself and knew that these were 6 graders who just needed the drama and if it wasn't him, it'd be someone else.
These kinds of stories get under my skin. What compels us as people to gang up on each other? To be relentlessly ruthless in taunting? Why can't we agree that differences are positive? It bothers me tremendously.
I'm happy that Mr. Gerber enabled every teen to make successful art. This says something about his integrity, I think.
Mrs. Mitchell suffered much the same fate, I'm afraid. Except that it wasn't tales of sexual misconduct, but those of other bizarre torture. All without substantiation. What I discovered as the year wore on was a very compassionate woman who was locked in a world of sadness and loneliness. She gave so much of herself to her students and too many were hellbent on giving her even a modicum of respect or cooperation. It made me sad. It still makes me incredibly sad.
And it makes me sad that Mr. Gerber had to endure what he did. I hope and pray he had someone special in his life who eased his daily troubles.
I know Mr. Gerber, My wife and I rented a house from him last year. He is a kind man. Even with his advanced age he spends a lot of his time doing volunteer work with the local senior center and is an active member of my church. There is no question in my mind he has a good heart and a deep love for the arts.
Post a Comment